Respectfully I think the point went over your head or I may not have explained it well, somebody roleplaying something that you cannot counterplay is not fair. The animal will always smell what it is trained to search for, no matter the circumstance. You cannot hide it through RP because it would require approved altRP. If you lie, you catch a nonRP punishment, and even if you tell the truth you often get asked to OOC check.
I do understand there’s a lot of roleplay that goes into this RP and the training is intensive, but I still think there’s just nothing you can do about it. If you comply it’s an arrest, if you evade it’s an arrest if it’s daytime