I wanna add something and with all my respect i think the punishment rule might need a recheck, lets look into the negativity and not only the positivity of it.
im pretty sure that it will be a forum war and factions will spam report each other so they get demotions to their ic enemies and this happened at azteca and triads period as i remember.
lets be real, imagine an active faction that have 30 members and not making punishment twice a month even if they have a good roleplay standard, its kinda impossible.
Okay we say that leaders kicked friends that making rulebreaks but what about the new recruits ? How the responsible people gonna know if they will fail or not even if they have good rp and high experience on the server?
we know that everyone can make mistakes at some points and no one is unmistakable.
my suggestion is to increase the number of rulebreaks but also you need to make monthly events and getting more roleplay creativity etc…
im not saying that factions can do rulebreaks without punishment but 2 is a small number for a gang that have 30 members.