Agg

My last post I'll make on this since we're all going around in circles. Like I said initially I'm new to GTA RPing so I don't have a lot of hours online just due to when I've been available to play but I've been able to poke around the forums and read reports and complaints that people post. I think the best way I can think of to sum up my points is that just because you haven't broken any rules (even though you did) doesn't mean that your RP is good enough. I read the rules as the baseline for the expectations, breaking them is bad but strictly obeying them doesn't equal good RP. Pulling from your last post for example, you mentioned that "one was in his car not engaging in the RP at all" - this is you making a determination as that something is safe for strictly on a player level, you're treating the other cop as out of play on a player level but from your characters perspective there are two cops there and you need to make the determination based on that second cop being someone who could drop you, in addition to the other people who were there who had guns.

You pulled a gun on the officer. The officer reacted appropriately to having a gun pulled on them. You also said that "No person who isnt law enforcement shouldnt even be aloud to pull there gun out on us. They should be fear RPing as a bystander and just watching what unfolds." . If you were in a situation where every other person didn't have guns this would make sense - your video has sort of that reaction from some players such as the EMTs turn and run back to their vans when they realize what's happening. If my character was there, he would have ran away or hid because he doesn't have a gun. In Los Santos a lot of people have guns and you pulled a gun on a police officer without knowing how many people there had guns and your friend being in handcuffs. There is no possible way for you to maintain complete control of that situation. How did you show appropriate care for your character's life and safety by pulling a gun in that situation?

You're basically saying here it doesn't matter about any of the other factors that are going on; I pulled a gun first so I win, you all have to do what I want. That isn't good roleplaying, you're trying to play the rules to the letter to say that you "won" the situation. I don't know you and I can only judge you from what your complaints are and your responses to everyone pointing out the flaws in your logic - it seems that you care more about winning than actually roleplaying.

I'm brand new to the server but from how you laid out your scenarios it sounds like you blatantly broke a bunch of rules: The one you mentioned about pointing a gun and typing. Intentionally submerging your vehicle (assuming you did it intentionally from the way you phrased it in your story). You aren't allowed to take another hostage for 1 OOC Week if police are involved, you said you did it again the day after. Robbery in the middle of the city (the first bullet of rule 15)